Syria – Obama: ” . . . America should take action”
03 Tuesday Sep 2013
03 Tuesday Sep 2013
03 Tuesday Sep 2013
Tags
First Appearance: http://en.alalam.ir/news/1512664
Published out of Iran yesterday: “Al-Qaeda militants kill 24 civilians near Ras al-Ain”.
Published via the anti-Jihad movement shortly after (and it’s making the rounds now): “Report – Syria: Al-Qaeda Force Passengers Off a Bus and Behead 24 of Them, Including a Mother And Baby.” Pat Dollard, September 2, 2013.
Sing along: “Tyrants to the right of me — fanatics to the left: stuck in the middle with you!”
* * *
Let’s compare notes.
Russia <–> Assad’s Baathist Syria <–> Ayatollah Khamenei’s Jew Hating and Genocidal Iran (officially; unofficially it may be better than the regime makes it look) : Qatar’s Sunni Islamic Ambitions <–> the Anglophile West (at least) <–> Syria’s Rebel Cause / (divided by) A Fanatic Islamist Complement.
For spice, add a dollop of chemical warfare.
And, remember, Putin, standing up for the power of money and secular Russian interests, even while fond of the Greek Orthodox Church (and I suspect of Israel too), seems to be saying, more or less, “let it burn”.
Considering who is fighting and what they are willing to do to one another . . . .
Obama, who probably by now hates this lurid spotlight, has to drag his heels a bit while mulling or preparing to block the further use of chemical weapons at the threshold and get Qatar (x Kingdom of Saudi Arabia) looking about right (no more wife beating — that has been announced) for a “greater virtue” argument and either bringing the AQ / MB adventurers into the Idris fold or getting them off the field to buttress that stance.
Good luck with that.
* * *
It hasn’t been a “cakewalk”.
It won’t be unless, until, when the day comes that the Syrians today bereaved, displaced, and refugee and just plain in the middle of a theater of war understand that they, no one else, occupy the center and middle of Syrian culture and society.
What they are about, what they will be about, what kind of lives their children may have to look forward to, what attitudes, beliefs, ethics, and values they may wish to own and hold dear and which they may care to repudiate — start with anti-Semitism and the hatred of Israel, please — will be decided between the familiar in tyrants and extremists if they do not fill out with their own energies and prayers General Idris’s or some other moderate center middle compassionate humanizing decent stance.
* * *
I know this blog has a small readership, if any, but wide distribution.
My advice if you’re “operational” or close enough for influence: get the savagery off the field, for demonstrations of greater cruelty and ever more breathtaking callousness and sadism do not become you.
Additional Reference
# # #
02 Monday Sep 2013
Tags
Copy and pasted here last week from the Wikipedia article cited:
Here is a Wikipedia listing for detailing armed strength on the rebel side (not including third-way Kurdish forces):
Free Syrian Army: 50,000[4] – 80,000[25]
Syrian Islamic Liberation Front: 37,000[4] (by May 2013)
Syrian Islamic Front: 13,000[4] (by May 2013)
Al-Nusra Front: 6,000[4] (by June 2013)
Foreign Mujahideen: 10,000 (by August 2013)[26]
Should we add up up the two units with “Islamic” in the title and the known “Al-Nusra Front” and predictably passionate “Mujahideen” to suggest that the tide in Islamic fanatics numbers more than 66,000 souls.
Here comes “shimmer“!
On my desktop at the moment: “Al Qaeda militants kill 24 civilians near Ras al-Ain,” Alalam, September 2, 2013, published out of Iran:
Al-Qaeda linked terrorists in Syria have beheaded all 24 Syrian passengers traveling from Tartus to Ras al-Ain in northeast of Syria, among them a mother and a 40-days old infant.
The piece launched by Iran’s anti-western / anti-American press has been picked up by similar other press, but it dovetails nicely with the existential state of affairs for Syria’s Kurdish community, which has indeed gathered and risen to meet the onslaught ventured by the Al Qaeda affiliates in Syria (on this blog, see “Kurdistan – Rojava” published last Thursday, August 29, 2013).
Anyone sincerely interested in quelling the latest in the Syrian theater’s celebration of death will have to stand against the same on the familiar two fronts:
Out here on the virtual berm overlooking the Wild Wild Web, one may wish, albeit with care, for broader, more frequent, and vetted professional journalism from the “back of beyond” in humanity, but the same that sling informational dirt in abundance — and sometimes create it under the “false flag” concept — have a bad reputation with journalists and assorted other do-gooders on various missions to feed, heal, or witness.
* * *
“We think if there is no strike, the regime is going to use chemical weapons and to kill, I’m afraid to say that in the coming days, not coming weeks, to kill more than 20,000 or 30,000 people, of our people … and that’s why we are waiting now for our friends in the Congress to make the right decision to support the president’s decision,” Idris said.
Kopan, Tal. “Syrian rebel general backs Barack Obama.” Politico, September 2, 2013.
Of the many personalities to which the world has been introduced in relation to Syria’s civil war, General Salim Idris may stand out as one with the cleanest hands in the mess. While fighting with the Assad regime, its Idris’s commanders who fight also with Al Qaeda, but how that works Out There — and how it works out — seems another patch for guesswork.
Or just plain guessing.
The braver than ever I will be Bill Roggio has been working this territory in his Long War Journal for months. The headlines and brief excerpts provide the contour of this part part of the story:
“Free Syrian Army issues ultimatum to al Qaeda over murder of commander.” July 13, 2013. From the cap on that piece:
Additionally, the killing of commanders and fighters by rival rebel groups is nothing new in Syria. Islamists have killed FSA commanders in the past, and vice versa. These incidents often occur due to local rivalries and competition for resources, not for ideological reasons. In this recent killing of an FSA commander, the issue wasn’t ideology, but access to a checkpoint in order to deploy forces
That’s some rough “office politics”!
* * *
“Free Syrian Army arming al Qaeda, ISIL, commander claims.” July 16, 2013.
* * *
Fast forward to last week:
The Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant, one of two al Qaeda affiliates operating in Syria, announced that it would coordinate with other Syrian rebel groups, including the Free Syrian Army, to take revenge for a chemical weapons attack last week in the capital that is said to have killed more than 300 people.
Roggio goes into detail about the makeup of the field and relationships on it, leaving doubts about General Idris’s control of FSA human assets and war materiel.
* * *
Grappling with largely untrained and at times undisciplined fighters, Salim Idris said in an interview that he is trying to turn local militias into a united force of some 120,000 men for a final push against President Bashar Assad.
Critics say the newly unified command structure he presides over lacks both the ground presence and the heavy weapons that are so desperately needed. Without both, they say, it will be impossible for him to forge a cohesive force from the thousands of fractious, fiercely independent rebel brigades arrayed against the still formidable military of President Bashar al-Assad.
Writing for the Huffington Post, Daniel Nisman noted back in June, “By bolstering the SMC, the U.S. and Saudi Arabia likely hope to incentivize rebel groups to become more moderate in their ideologies in order to meet their requirements for future military aid” (Nisman, Daniel, “The First Real Test for Moderates in the Syrian Opposition,” The Blog, Huffington Post, June 17, 2013).
I fear to say it but may suggest to the public relations folk representing the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Qatar and others interested in planting a new Sunni Islam state in Syria: the global anti-Jihad — call them “Islamophobes” if thou wish — ain’t buying the phrase “incentivize to become more moderate in their ideologies.” In such ears and minds, from the desktops of the masses to the halls of Congress, the Is’phobes are still trying to figure out if there is a moderate Islam given milepost statements like this one (from 2008):
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan rejected attempts to call Turkey the representative of moderate Islam. “It is unacceptable for us to agree with such a definition. Turkey has never been a country to represent such a concept. Moreover, Islam cannot be classified as moderate or not,” Erdoğan said, speaking at Oxford Centre for Islamic Studies late Thursday.
Hurriyet Daily News. “Prime Minister objects to ‘moderate Islam’ label.” (2008).
* * *
The moderate minded may find agreeably present and numerous Muslim humanists as contemporary and humanist as any Christian, Jewish, or other contemporary liberal humanist on earth this day — and effectively comprising substantial societies, as did that which unseated President Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt recently — but in Syria, the voice raising Cain and getting plenty of the world’s attention isn’t that one: it’s this other that promises moderation while other of its kin abet the funding those with whom Syria’s Kurdish Community finds itself fighting for its very existence.
So General Idris may find himself the voice of moderation but not the commander of it throughout his battle space.
I would like to see this article updated: “AFP, “Syrian rebel chief Idriss emerges as key interlocutor for west,” Al Arabiya, June 14, 2013.
It has got the theme right: General Idris is a modern man, a reasoning man, a good man, but out in the field, the barbaric act of just one soldier reaching into the chest cavity of one of the fallen to pull out an organ and take a bit of it has dampened that image, and, so far, that damage has not been reversed.
From Paul Wood’s article referenced above (inline):
“We condemn what he did,” said the general. “But why do our friends in the West focus on this when thousands are dying? We are a revolution not a structured army. If we were, we would have expelled Abu Sakkar. But he commands his own battalion, which he raised with his own money. Is the West asking me now to fight Abu Sakkar and force him out of the revolution? I beg for some understanding here.”
Wood, Paul. “Face-to-face with Abu Sakkar, Syria’s ‘heart-eating cannibal’. BBC, July 5, 2013.
* * *
To say, “they don’t think like we do” is to distill with a cliche the ambiguity shown General Idris down to its cognitive, linguistic, and spiritual essence.
The embrace of barbarism and cruelty, the belief that greater demonstrations of both serve to control one’s enemies, in fact sabotage Syria’s revolutionary front even though Assad’s army and its behavior, perhaps keeping in line with that description of the grammar of the conflict, exceeds in scope and intensity the same lunacy.
# # #
01 Sunday Sep 2013
Tags
chemical weapons, conflict, ethics, good society, law, morals, political science, politics, rules of engagement, rules of war, Syria, war
Chemical and biological weapons are absolutely prohibited under international humanitarian law. Debates and questions surrounding the alleged use of chemical weapons in Syria are not fading away. Robert Mardini, the ICRC’s head of operations for the Near and Middle East, explains the organization’s position.
Tell me about the world in which you would like to live.
Will it be a world that holds itself to time honored ethical and moral standards?
Will it be a world in which self-awareness and the awareness of others inspires an integrating compassion and consideration for the humanity shared?
Will it be a world in which the most notable and powerful of public speakers may be trusted to keep their own laws, to restrain themselves from excessive or unbridled appetites, and to tell the truth whether it becomes them or not?
If you should wish to live in some other world, don’t bother with this blog.
* * *
Unknown to Syrian officials, U.S. spy agencies recorded each step in the alleged chemical attack, from the extensive preparations to the launching of rockets to the after-action assessments by Syrian officials. Those records and intercepts would become the core of the Obama administration’s evidentiary case linking the Syrian government to what one official called an “indiscriminate, inconceivable horror” — the use of outlawed toxins to kill nearly 1,500 civilians, including at least 426 children.
Bishara, Marwan. “US and Syria: the calculus of war.” Al Jazeera, August 30, 2013.
ICRC. “The Geneva Conventions of 1949 and their Additional Protocols”. PDF Address: The Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949.
ICRC. “War and international humanitarian law”.
Raum, Tom. “Syria: Conflict, an alleged chemical attack, and fallout.” MPR News, August 31, 2013.
Wikipedia. “Hague Conventions of 1899 and 1907”.
# # #
29 Thursday Aug 2013
We are fighting America’s war on terror right here on the ground,” says Kurdish fighter Dijwar Osman. “Our enemies are those al Qaeda fighters who want to destroy our 4,000-year-old Kurdish culture. These jihadists come from Belgium, Holland, Morocco, Libya, and other countries. Unfortunately, the U.S. and Turkey are on the side of al Qaeda, just like the U.S. was on al Qaeda’s side in Afghanistan during the ’80’s
This is the hard punch from the same article: “They have their own army and police here, names of towns have been changed from Arabic to Kurdish, and the Kurdish language is being taught in schools — something that was forbidden under the Assad regime.”
Call this lead still hot:
People’s Defense Units (YPG) and Women’s Defense Units (YPJ) guerrillas in Rojava are engaged in fighting al-Qaeda-linked armed groups since 15 July 2013. A remarkable part of the region has been cleared of the gang groups as a result of the resistance by Kurdish guerrillas as well as by local people supporting them in the villages, towns, districts and provinces of western Kurdistan.
Firatnews. “The Kurdish resistance in the villages of Rojava.” August 29, 2013.
An Islam tolerant of others may be tolerated, and for all outside its Ummah, as much seems a theme heavily argued.
However, the better nature of human nature may fit with nature: a still wild species would seem Homo sapiens sapiens in a still wild world where abundance and variety fill out to their edges every physical, political, and social niche. There are no tribes that would regard themselves as other than a “First People” but even the Jews — perhaps simply the Jews — recognize the chosen qualities in others and unless assaulted leave each to go their way.
* * *
“Rojava Genocide”, posted to YouTube August 9, 2013.
* * *
Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) Ministry of Peshmerga secretary-general Jabbar Yawar told Asharq Al-Awsat that the Kurdish military delegation “informed the Iraqi side of the Peshmerga ministry’s complete readiness to send its forces to any spot in Iraq to confront terrorism, in the event of the federal Ministry of Defense requesting this.”
Asharq Al-Awsat. “Kurdish Peshmerga ready to confront terrorism across Iraq.” August 4, 2013.
After so many years of state-related parlay, the pressure placed on the Kurds by the forces of Islamic Jihad seems to have wrested Kurdish space from state control in Syria and encouraged Kurdish martial consolidation and political solidarity in line with self-government.
While Putin plays Syria for all it’s worth — I should think the Greek Orthodox Church and the Ayatollah’s enterprise have the deepest of natural disaffinities — and Cameron plus Obama work with Qatar plus the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, history (plus a little chaos theory by way of the Al Qaeda types) may have just brought the Kurdish community an opportunity to settle down to defending itself in its own space.
We shall see.
* * *
Lest any get carried away with the above map, reference back to Wikipedia’s “Syrian Kurdistan” page may be helpful. From that page:
During the Syrian civil war, the Popular Protection Units (YPG) were created under the administration of the Kurdish Supreme Committee to control the Kurdish inhabited areas in Syria. On 19 July 2012, the YPG captured the city of Kobanê (Ayn al-Arab), and the next day captured Amûdê and Efrîn.[6] The two main Kurdish groups, theKurdish National Council (KNC) and the Democratic Union Party (PYD), afterwards formed a joint leadership council to run the captured cities.[6] By 24 July, the Syrian Kurdish cities of Dêrika Hemko (Al-Malikiyah), Serê Kaniyê (Ra’s al-‘Ayn), Dirbêsî (Al-Darbasiyah) and Girkê Legê (Al-Ma’bada) had also come under the control of the Popular Protection Units. The only major Kurdish inhabited cities that remained under government control were Hasaka and Qamishli.[7][8]
* * *
Sky News Kurdish Women Fighters Battle In Aleppo
Although the above clip appears to have been posted to YouTube today, I believe it actually comes from Stuart Ramsay’s report for Sky News, “Syria: Kurdish Women Fighters Battle in Aleppo,” May 20, 2013. From that source:
It is a mess, and the government with support from Hezbollah and Iran is reinvigorated, making or taking back new and old ground daily.
But the revolution is ongoing. Huge swathes of the country are outside government control and the many, many people I meet are happy with that.
Additional Reference
Colling, Andre. “The impact of the Syrian conflict on neighbouring states.” News24, August 27, 2013.
Huffington Post. “Turkey Kurdish Conflict”.
Kurd Press. “Number of Syrian in Kurdistan Region exceeds 200,000.” August 28, 2013.
# # #
29 Thursday Aug 2013
The other great American ally in the region, Israel, has for the most part recused itself from the Syrian conflict. Its only direct action has been to strike Hezbollah supply networks that might have carried threatening missiles into Lebanon, and to shell Syrian fighters who brought their war too close to the Israeli frontier. In fact, although Saudi Arabia and Israel are technically enemies, their interests coincide very closely in Syria. Both want to see Iran weakened, neither wants to see Assad last, and neither want to see the Brotherhood or al Qaeda take control. In such a situation, a protracted war draining the resources of its enemies is not the worst thing that could happen from Israel’s point of view.
We don’t put humans in zoos (except for criminals best kept in cages): some “uncontacted people” we, well, the world of scholars, try to leave alone; some primitive tribes enjoy nominal to effective state-based protective security with freedom to choose their communal way exclusively or assimilate incrementally under their own volition.
Noting that and sometimes likening Sunni vs. Shiite strife to “two mad wasps in a bell jar,” one may well view Syria’s agony and its surround of political drivers, from the post-Soviet interest of neo-oligarch Russia to the alien-to-the-west ambitions of Iran and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, as taking place in a political crucible so isolated as to be compared an island or pit expressly designed for viewing Homo sapiens sapiens at its worst.
It’s not called a “theater” for nothin’.
* * *
Last Wednesday, in the hours after a horrific chemical attack east of Damascus, an official at the Syrian Ministry of Defense exchanged panicked phone calls with a leader of a chemical weapons unit, demanding answers for a nerve agent strike that killed more than 1,000 people. Those conversations were overheard by U.S. intelligence services, The Cable has learned.
I may disagree here with Christopher Dickey as regards the effects of a punitive strike against the Syrian military to discourage additional chemical weapons attacks: the mentality involved has long proven itself beyond criticism, conscience, and prudence.
Maher is accused of multiple human rights abuses and is considered the most feared man in Syria. Aside from the recent chemical attacks, there are several examples of horrible atrocities carried out by troops he commands. In March 2011, his fourth division lead a siege against a “group of schoolboys” who were calling for Bashar to leave. Maher ordered them all killed.
Michelson, Brad. “Maher al-Assad: Top 10 Facts You Need to Know.” Heavy, August 28, 2013.
About that group of schoolboys: Chulov, Martin. “Did Assad’s ruthless brother mastermind alleged Syria gas attack?” The Guardian, August 24, 2013.
* * *
Theologist Thomas Berry placed man as the enabled living agent in an unfolding earth process: we’re able to live with the earth, respond to our own presence in it (as we do with anti-pollution controls, laws, and strategies). Beside that thought I would place the idea that the World Wide Web and its social networks form a nerve-type skein around the globe’s human affairs — even “human process” — too, and we know where life is burning and where it is sweet, where correction is wanted and peace is needed.
I’ve never really liked the brand name “Google” (goes with a child’s rattling toy) nor the slogan “Islamic Awakening” but ironically, oddly, both terms may refer to an organismic acquisition of a new consciousness and conscience. Not since God sewed skins for Adam and Even on their way out into their human journey has mankind enjoyed such an expansion of awareness.
I’ll spare you the “Pale Blue Dot” on this post.
What’s happening in Syria today: evil.
Whatever the cloaks and covers, the excuses and the temptations, it’s not what anyone wants or should want.
What is happening around Syria, whether with concerns for refugees, with “tracking” the conflict, with ideas in an Awesome Conversation taking place around the world in real time 24/7/365, that is what is wanted.
Wake up! Wake up! Wake up!
# # #
28 Wednesday Aug 2013
Tags
On 11 June 2013, President Vladimir Putin acknowledged that President Assad’s position had led to the current situation in Syria. He stated on Russian state media that:
“Syria as a country was rife for some kind of change. And the government of Syria should have felt that in due time and should have undertaken some reform. Had they done that, what we’re seeing in Syria today would have never happened.”
Russian mercenaries on rebell side in syria? (Published June 10, 2013).
* * *
Last year, the Syrian government presented the UN Security Council with lists of hundreds of foreign nationals who had been killed fighting against government forces in Syria. The lists included mercenaries from Arab countries, Europe, and Russia’s North Caucasus region, including Chechnya.
RIA Novosti. “CIS Security Services to Track Syria Mercenaries.” May 15, 2013.
Russia evacuated 116 Russian citizens and nationals of other ex-Soviet states on two planes belonging to the emergencies ministry which flew them from the Syrian port city of Latakia, the ministry said on Wednesday.
The flights came as expectations grow of Western military action against president Bashar al-Assad’s regime over claims it used chemical weapons in an attack outside the Syrian capital last week.
Yet Russia continues to vote with the Palestinians at the United Nations, to invite Hamas to Moscow, to help Iran with its nuclear programme and to sell missiles to Syria, which then end up in the hands of Lebanon’s Hezbollah. In truth, a degree of disconnect has marked Russia’s relations with Israel ever since its foundation in 1948.
* * *
Russia has been (quietly) channeling civilian and military assets out of and away from Syria for some time, so while its talk supports the Assad regime, its walk appears in the other direction.
Whatever Russia’s true underlying stance may be — I happen to think it has to do with making money at the moment — its interests may reside more with the wild, wild west than with the interests of Islamic theocracies (and also more with the Greek Orthodox Church and Russia’s own grand heroic mythos than with emulation of foreign comic book inventions).
While Russia plays around with what it wants “Syria Next” to look like — because “Syria Dark Star” (as I like to call it) has had its bridges leading back to the recent past burned, most of them by its itself through relentless bombing and tank campaigns — it has become a general war zone for all comers.
Here is a Wikipedia listing for detailing armed strength on the rebel side (not including third-way Kurdish forces):
Free Syrian Army: 50,000[4] – 80,000[25]
Syrian Islamic Liberation Front: 37,000[4] (by May 2013)
Syrian Islamic Front: 13,000[4] (by May 2013)
Al-Nusra Front: 6,000[4] (by June 2013)
Foreign Mujahideen: 10,000 (by August 2013)[26]
One might ask whether in its post-Soviet existence, Mother Russia has any obligations to Syria’s constituency in its entirety, and if so, what those might be, and what it needs to do to fulfill the obligations of the relationships, that as opposed to merely fulfilling arms deliveries contracts.
On 11 June 2013, President Vladimir Putin acknowledged that President Assad’s position had led to the current situation in Syria. He stated on Russian state media that:
“Syria as a country was rife for some kind of change. And the government of Syria should have felt that in due time and should have undertaken some reform. Had they done that, what we’re seeing in Syria today would have never happened.”[67]
Wikipedia. “Russia’s role in the Syrian civil war”.
(I’d quote from source “67” but it wants me to subscribe. If it were just one outlet or a few, maybe, but for the fast overviews I’ve been doing, I will need a sponsor with deeper pockets than my own and as good an attitude about looking at what “conflict, culture, language, and psychology” look like worldwide from the Second Row Seat to History, the common shared news platform provided by the World Wide Web).
The Mideastwire Blog. “Russia says manpads in Syria theatre.” October 24, 2012.
The Voice of Russia. “US, Turkey worried by Syria mercenaries.” August 8, 2013.
28 Wednesday Aug 2013
The 8200 unit of the Israeli Defence Forces, which specialises in electronic surveillance, intercepted a conversation between Syrian officials regarding the use of chemical weapons, an unnamed former Mossad official told Focus. The content of the conversation was relayed to the US, the ex-official said.
The 8200 unit collects and analyses electronic data, including wiretapped telephone calls and emails. It is the largest unit in the IDF.
Funky timing: for four or five days, not one mention of specifically “who” in the where, what, how, and why of the chemical weapons attack in the Damascus suburbs — and today the answer seems to be unavoidable in online search and dated back to August 24 (see the Debka File citation in reference).
Nonetheless, if attributed to Maher al-Assad’s command, then the world has a figure already steeped in legendary criminal malice: there’s not much he can do to cast himself into even a darker light.
Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the Turkish prime minister, said in March 2011 that Maher’s actions during the uprising approached “savagery,” and urged Bashar to send him into exile.
AP. “Report: Russia to send marines to Syria.” The Daily Caller, June 18, 2012. Relayed here for the photograph that tops the piece; it actually seems to cover a Russian defensive effort to secure civilian and military assets exiting Syria a little more than a year ago.
BackChannels. “In Foreign Affairs – Putin – Analysis from March 2013.” March 13, 2013.
Bryen, Shoshana. “The Incredible Shrinking US-Israel Security Cooperation.” June 27, 2012.
El-Khoury, Rajeh. “Moscow Hints at Break with Assad.” Al Monitor, February 2, 2012.
# # #