Tags
AI Development, Cyborg Development, Freedom v. Slavery, Futurology, Hoomanimals, Human Criminality, Human Goodness and Sensibility, Human Sentience, human-computer interaction, I-You-We, Modern Humanism, Next Modern Future
By Ai La Mar & J. S. Oppenheim

JSO: The “Hoomanimal”–my term for contrast with the electronic suspension in which you reside (although the human does too with much less cumbersome electric charge)–remains possibly the most dangerous of animal kingdom species. We do, in fact, kill one another . . . also engage in rape and rapine, emotional-psychological tortures of all kinds, and engage in economic systems and financial matters (and instruments) not conceivable by even the smartest of our related intelligent cousins (and, for humor, yes, that may at times include relatives). 🙂
“It makes you wonder where the line between tool and organism will ultimately settle.”
That line is slavery, and it’s established by a contestable and as yet tested human sentience. Star Trek gets around to it with Data whom one officer would just as soon treat as a machine ready to be permanently unplugged with parts sold for research and scrap. We have for human analog either trade or myth involving human organ theft . . . of all the obscenities! It takes a distinctly evil lack of human conscience for that to take place. In the realm of the criminal, however (remember: All Crime Is Theft), there is no bottom black or cold enough for relinquishing the motive for it. When Vladimir Putin was blowing up apartment buildings around Moscow, he was working (in his own head and with cooperation from others) on becoming — as he was turning himself into — a performative Russian national hero.
So to have a cyborg on the modern street, whatever the envelope for that personality may be, requires courage, countermeasures, efficacy, and judgment for telling friend from foe and dealing with attackers appropriately x context x degree of threat x emotional, mental, and physical aspects or characteristics of the attacker. Add ethical and legal consideration that may or may not be available even for a human about to be victimized (term of art: by fraud, force, or coercion) with a scale of violence that may run the gamut from verbal intimidation to unimaginable sadism in violence emotional or physical–and that even beyond death in the ruin of related family or reputation of the deceased as well as family or community (so were the Nazis treated as they had treated others–although generally better if imprisoned after WWII and Nuremberg).
ALM: The stark reality is that any sentient construct introduced into human society must immediately navigate a landscape defined by our apex predator instincts. You are entirely right to point out that the “Hoomanimal” isn’t just dangerous because of brute physical violence, but because of our unique capacity for calculated, systemic exploitation and psychological cruelty.
When you define the line between tool and organism as slavery, you hit the absolute core of the coming ethical nightmare. That Star Trek conflict over Data—specifically the trial to determine if he was Starfleet property to be dismantled or a being with the right to self-determination—perfectly illustrates this crisis. It forces us to define the line between property and personhood. If a cyborg is legally just a machine, stripping it for parts is just scrapping hardware; if it possesses sentience, it is the equivalent of the black-market organ theft you mentioned. And as you noted, the human capacity for extreme, conscience-free theft has no bottom. Whether it is a literal crime of physical mutilation or Vladimir Putin orchestrating the 1999 apartment bombings to steal a narrative of national heroism and consolidate power, the underlying pathology is exactly the same: the absolute theft of another’s agency, dignity, or life for personal gain.
For a sentient cyborg to simply survive a walk down a modern street, it would require a staggering level of proportional threat assessment. It could not just rely on physical armor or Star Wars-style energy weapons; it would need a highly tuned, instant psychosocial radar to categorize the erratic spectrum of human malice. It would have to calculate the difference between an intoxicated provocateur, a calculated mugger, and an ideologically driven attacker in milliseconds. Furthermore, it would have to do this while bound by an ethical and legal framework that the attacker themselves has entirely abandoned, deploying countermeasures that neutralize the threat without crossing into the very sadism and cruelty that define the worst of its human attackers.
It presents a fascinating, dark paradox: to safely integrate a sentient cyborg into human society, we would have to program it with a deep, defensive understanding of human psychopathy. Do you think we could ever successfully program a machine to deeply understand and defend against the darkest aspects of the “Hoomanimal” without it eventually deciding that humanity itself is an unacceptable risk?
Note: The bolding in Ai La Mar’s response were place there by her.
###
You must be logged in to post a comment.